Sera Sandesh-- A Book Review in Bengali

 ^r : Prrc LZAS

~e@ 

 ^r 1368 - 1387
FABl  A ; @r@ - ~S^ cAUr; ha R ~Ue@H - FABl ; T @r - MK 1388 ; p -378 ; T - 150.00 v@; ISBN 81-7066-866-7 ]

|| 1 ||

~T Prrc AaU SSS m, SSS , SSS PcAOnF ArAF g ; ZS @S j@Av @rSem c An@wf ~T ~AoF AaU S | AaU ofO^ @ A "TMO@" An@ - OfS, AFTA ; AaU c AF @Av @Ar "@" - US c ScfS, vBS, J-gJ, cJvU A wv ZiF U ~T vqvc; AaU "Arf"; A@aAS  d U fSrS OoF "A@r gf"- F-T, a aAc TpXo ; "~S^ TU" ZS ~U An@ AS, ecn aS  cd  j@AS - U @@cc - ^, A@A@, wwU, ~BS c B ZS B^AS, UZ@ @\SBw a ; "sw^" ecn A@ ArAF p "av A" AL AaUS mSc ~l ~AZU ASwf - ZS @f ZJ cAXof @vS ~ ASAT AUZS ~T mU ceU TmvTrq g@ TAI | vAUAgrS ZS m, c ~@rcHf AaU w\ ~ |

Ar @ ~AcrF @T @T T ~ aAc-a-w\-@ cqn ; @r@ wA @rS, BcgAm cUg, Tm ; ~Sc @S ceU @qv UZ@-@Ac - T/SSf/gK/@TQf - @Av ST jq ToF cR mpA BU - "qnS @", "U IJAv TwAv"- "BSU A TZ cR/TvJAv AS sR" oS eA ~T TZ TZ A ZS | @U@ "TSfK" jce TASf "~^K" ST@ w^U Av ACS  @ q w^ |

j@c @AO@JO BSF AaUS @T, ^A@r, AQHS, swf^S | q o dU T^@T  - B^, TAS@, ^cc; SfS  - A@fAv, c ; ArcT Oncf - KcoS, wcoS ; UfU TBT @ d @ ZU R | ~@v c cU vAS, WS,  re@; "OJ " AcgkAgkKH, "TAI aU" TAS@ c^FoF; cXoc c "a @U @U"; Mf^TS TZoF "OAUl O^", "T @Uf ZJ" | AcAr R @TA AaU S - ~r@  gcSc rA~; of^S  ~Sc @S STf UZ@ OS - A@S, AmvgSS, T, mv ; @US  R ~fr coS ~Sc BU gS | jqc AF j@ AcrK @^mU AcB @ "^r", ~T R ArQ g j@ ASZJ R cUfU gTF Z;  q Oq R rwU ToFR ATr @ ASAc TSm,   TS Aw^ |

SS s ^r TA@n T eZF @Ar  cf^ rcK - 1368 S PcrZ T | Av @ TS a jq ew : j@, A@ An@ "~Tp"R @r d AaU jq j@q T jce cf @@ r@ ceU TA@n qA j@Av dLkH gkAT@ US @AaU @wBAv | q, F S AA@  J j@Av ASc^ AaUT s r r@ R Ar\U AAS j@Av A@ An@ S @S, ST ^r, Zc c j@Av cT^f v qASS TZn | Kv r@ T sZS FABl  R ~SF ^r @r B @aS, ZS AcSTW cB TS @A  ABmv J @r ~STA A ~mf@ @S, @H j@q ST ~@Av An@ cTS | cc q Zc  @@ AOAi AUZ BSS s J An@Av ~oSAcU jce Rq STAv R J @S Ac Sq; j Uq c  ^r AA@ S:@r |

^r T d 1320 U 1U PcrZ ~l jAU 1913 | j Ai@ j@ ca ~w  ~UA^@ Tw c AwAaU vqvAS@ BB | ~ Ai@  T  ScU m US cf^S i@ | ^A@r OMof S ^r T @r - J ASB aZS, kH ASB ZO ; An@Av T AS ~S UR ^ @wB, IUTU TUv, g -@U R ACS aAc T | T eZF ^A@r AO gkAT@Av jq e@US wA^ a ; AAS AUZaS, "... ~T s ^r Zq  Av H ~a |  Zq gU Uw ~  rf cU  | ~T jq s An@ZAS ^r ST Uq @U AS@v Am qa, qR sA jq Av H @ - ~l q A sA @U gU Uw ~ A@a @ , cq q ^r ST @ qc |" ^r ~w ~R Av av An@ cAAaU - T "Z R Zf" - Zc c ceU gK T Ar An@ jce  @@ ca  T@U | Avq oS F ^A@r jce UZ@ AU@ gw AAS R J Ac ~SFSF | ~T r ZS aAc N@ PA @ R aS @S cFcmq AaU S cU wU | AAS ASB jq c sA ArQ @US jce ASB aZS  vS, N@ AAxve j cFcm @US - o r S, AcUR q  ~F S-j a cqn ~@i re R T AaU |

jqgc ArAF d U j@ SS sw | ^r ZS AUZaS ^A@r, cf^S, ~cSf^S jce ZS@ c c c UZ@ | ~ @TcAR Ag A@a @T sS S - 1321 U j@Av eZF cdU c AT @Ac "AZOA", UZ@ @T  -

"J AaU, B, (cF@H TAS S)
 wU JBd @TS  BAS S |"

d U ~cU cU AAB T Xgv @Ac - ~BAc, BT@U, ASTU A, AcTfS ~S^ | A@ 1915 U 20 Ac TpF U ^A@r jce ~ir ca cA @T @ US ~q ca cA ^r An@ | 1921 U s^ OUU ^r mHsw,  @UB ~n^ US @T | ~m ToFq AAS OAU wUS ^r S, A@ 1923 U J TpF  c^  wU ^r | A@aAS  @T TBgq AcS  S ~c d U  jce ~ASAT gc UR OUU 1342 U s^ |  j@cq c^ |

JAOr ca @vU | T g  qhaUS R ~SH ~c "^r" @r B @US FABl, J  AaUS @Ac gK TZoF ; T eZF cdU T 1961, gAT@ AUZUS ^A@r TB T HFU Oncf - "jAS  ^r ~c ja - @ ~r ~ ~S^  @ ~ cH @Aa | ~c ^r W W ASTU A ~ ~S^ g ZU A@, A R ~S^ ToF A aUT ScAXo Av U@,  TS @T cpAAU Ac@Ar @ A@ | ^r ScB^ @ !" T A@ SS ^r @ AaUS FABl R gK; ca  @ U sw AUS UfU TBT ; jR A@aAS  sw AUS HFU Oncf T SAUSf r jce J mTf ~r@S^ r US TA@ ^r @r@ | ~UOF w^Av ^r An@ T @A ca @Ar UZ R aAc @ "ca AS, aJ@ AS" c @ j@ AScAO e@US | UZ caq @ AL AaUS ASBSq - UfU, SAUSf R FABl ; S R ~B g ASaS FABl | gkAT@ AUZ AaS UfU TBT, BASaS - "av Z Oq jq BfcSv @ gU | BS Oq cQ| @ A@ Wva, Wva, Wv sha | TSK T TSK Z Oq | jTS TSK s  ~a, s gU@ gU ~ T^@ T^ cU | s UAU cq; s WpH @ o ATF@ AS@ ~ @JAT@ | c  s BF SF@AT ~ be | s Acr @pA@  SFsF Bw A m | s TS  | j c  ~T i@ ZArR @ Oq | ZAr @ S U ~T c Oq cp |" S, @STq cp S, Tv v, S S, COC cqAv  ASUq ~ ZAr ~ ~SAcU ~S^ g ic s @S c Ar TS | j TH,  ca r rAv TH jce TH eZF  ^ B | ^r B @ !

S ~TU ^r

|| 2 ||

@f @ ZS ^r TA@n ? @f ~a jq @A ca (PcrZ 1368 - POn 1387) 240-Av eZF TT  ^r ? a c A@a - w\, @Ac, c^, a, Ar@ @ASf - w^ ZFS - @ - ~Fg, qA, AcS; ~  J@ J@ TFAB@, oJoJ, JAU, aAc ~ rN ZU, @vS | TS , j@Av eZF FABl d @US AOnSvF UZ AsAw, A R U w\ ~\m\ @iT |  eZFAU a U i@-Ai@ UZ  ASAv AOnSvF | jce FABl B gK H A cAI AUS A@gc q AOnSvF ~cUcS OUAhOn ASTH , A@gc j@ rv @ ~SF rv, prF @ prF^ s  |

ceU ArAF SfOAn c@UfS Z ; @ Sf ca ca ^S Acq sS, cArgwq n^S - ~ Sf@  @Jv, ASO @Jv T ASAcc T U R @S rAm  S ~of | ~dH cdH R A@HTU @ASf - "~dH cdH q gq , rS ; U A@U U  ; cS AH M o", ~ "A@HTU cf @kvv@ A  S ; @BUU wq w TAaAv cA  S |" (i@T IAU, ATn R WK) ~cmv roS A@av O U ^r, cS @UB AA^U jce ^r ~SFT @ SAUSf r @UT - J w^@ASf oS OAn OAv A@rf - @U, TU, cU R vU, ~l "w^ wU"| TU g   gc, " Z SAU oA AUq @Ac AUZ Uc wv @@ |" @U cA@, @c@, ASg; cU ZAS@v gf, ~\q TZ @J @J j s ; vU @ASf @@ | OBS j@q mU , @ mvU, c s SS Bw ~ BA  ~Fg | cTS w^ e@AU a "wU R AAccf F", (p 200) j@v  A@ OS - ^r @r 1386  |

1970 U J TpF ~w s^ ^r ASAT AUZaS rA^ c^FoF ; T-cf jq UZ@ j@Av oS OAn Arc, ~\cA aU - ZS wJ wBAS,  ArcBf SU sw  Zc @T c jce  R cfL AO A US pA ~@KH @ | Arc AT@ ST @ - @ AS  ASB wT @ AU jAaU jce @@ ~r AAaUS ArcBf-BSSf ABBcq | rA^ BfcS  ~o@vq @va T, 1952 U @ AAS mfgc SAScf - T qA R gkwU J SZH | Arc w\AU Ai@ AA@ F, mrT R ~Fg  a UZ@ ~^pA, gK Bfc R USAcfS co; fWAS ~Ag J AOnSvF UZ - ~\@ Av US dQ, A r rNf Ti r BF^ rNAOn | ~   aq FAB ~J@ aAc | "Arc W-W @"(p 23) @ASfAv jq w^ j@ TkUFcS esBS |

a j@Av U w^@ASf, 1387 ^r @Ar "wU@oT F" (p 350) - @U@ vgkAT@ w\ ; gTH Sq cUq co Bv ~SAm ; "gU@ ~ Wc^f ~cm kB SF AUZaS, q Z-Qlv j@v @T |" cAUw @ j@ ^ cSA Ac ~U OA O ; A@ cFv TSF S @H s-W O jAaU  cA^ j@ ~^ BfcSAc, AsAS ~S@ ca ~w ~TA@ j@Av AcrAcFU wcKHw @B @ @ j@ WvS U ~^  sS R @U@ A ~S | F ~JO  U lf,  ~ sw  OA R ZS | @ASf TH R Tg @ ~S@ ~SK R H a ~ ~a ceU R qeAB vqxv c^ ~UOS R cHS | w\Av  @TcA i@ Ai@ ~S@q jq AcKAU AS ~ cAr @ BS ~wf c | jq @ASf U T ZAS @ q F ToS @R J@ ~Ags @SAS c AUr@ BSSAS | sAR q ZAS ~ Tn AS cJOAaUS, j-AcK SfAw ~A U ~ c S ASEOq |

cAr c AXf i o U ~ j@Av ~A | cf  U  Tc Z @ j :Z @r @US s AAS ~w @ ~FxvTxv @ SAS, @H m ZJZJA ~S@AS o J  S c  | A@  AS @Uq J cA @ S jU U @a s AT: m ZS aS |  sq @ c ATAU w\Av TS jce gwF |

e@US ~a FABl  ~ ASAv UZ - "T\U SfdAS w\" (p 145), Uq @FU "BFcRA@" ~cUcS UZ @Ac "Bc Z@f" (p 260) jce " " ST ~R j@Av w\ (p235) | sAR i@ c ~r cT Tv c S,  re@ j@Av w\ @U TB ~ gfKHgc BT jce e@USAv c^  | Zc c ~S @Hq re@ c waS, c gc qha @ " " ST Tv w\Av cU sA j@Av re@-@ASf SR s; AcrK @ re@ s w\ cv AcorZ @i "oSoSF y g" wSAv AaU | Zc c Av T re@@ASf jce ST co "cFTsnf A" - ZS TUw Hf w ~Jrv w^ ~ wU "AA^A, AA^A" ~RB cAS R TS  | ~U mAvrOO @UB cfH ~oF@ AnU@r re@ J cU ASvS, O@  ~ cv AcorZ ATU sgc T rSq ~T TS Q i@@ fWmf HTo FS cAS UAaUS, U  SAS | U T UwAaU ZAS@v cAr |

~ ~S@ A@a TAHT a jq U e@US | ~a cf^S Av SAv@ -"A TS" w\Av SvF AAaUS AQfr  (p 87) jce "The King and the Rebel" @M@SvF BwA^ gMAT@ @p ceU ~Sc "B R Bf" (p 14)| cf^S jq qeAB @M@ SAv@Av AUZAaUS rA^AS@S ~rT AcFU ananf qeAB rZS BSF | ~a TSUU woF cf^mpAOH "@cc" (p 21), AQATS S SA-SAS@ UZ AOAi A@ec^f "wa ST cWrU" (p 33), f^S i@ Tw wT aAv c sR @ASf "j@ g\U@ w\" (p 42), cf^ BfcSf@ g@T TZoF "@Ac R ScU y" (p 197), sZS @Ac y Zc R  ~rT SUcc@ @ cUUS, "jc ~S @ S R @ ZS c |"

@A @B AS r@ R cAr T ATU cf AaUS AAF@ swrO^ TBT (1882-1974); AAS Acer rNf To  g BfcSsn AcK ^r @@Av mpA@ AUZAaUS | cTS w^ e@AU a J "mpA@H" (p 44) OSAv -  SSS  AZ R cSBU ~ST cHS | c@U U swrO^ AF Bw kH Acmp | @cf,  R ~SFSF ToFswf g @Ac AcK J wgf ~UOSAU SSS C TMUc @xvA@ gcK ~fc BSf jce SS @ a AO | "AwAA mpA" (p 229) ST ~@Av gwF mpA@ AUZaS ^A@r gq A^ A@r OMof | ZS a S ^r @, @T  j@Av AcZF @Ac rf Sf \UZ a, SfAv a AwAA r ToF Aq jce   cA g AS @AaUS ^A@r | ~ a Tr cf cw\ "cf @ R Aa @" (p 115) - Sccf ~TU w\, Aa T^^ TT q cKfS aXcAr @ q qA @AS c @ c@ cAS ZBS v@ cTUT Ui @ @ASf | w\Av  jq j@q T AS UZ jce c@U ~w  J "~Jo TAS@" SFAv @ TS @A AU | ~a Av SfA@TkU@ w\ - re@ c^FoF "gcS^ @rfT" (p 34) jce S^ c AO "TAS@ F" (p 39)| ~ SH wewoF A w\ "Ar A@" (p 83) -w\Av OTl@, A@ UZ@ ^r @Ar w\ g ~T j@^ A U "AO TBB", s 1968 U Sw ^r cAAaU | ~r cf OS "~U vAS" (p 326) ~@Av TB UZ, A@gc J cARU aU cgc Z vAS OAnAv T jAaU SH wewoF |  ~crF ~SFn AcKAv AS AcmA gc AUZaS fe@ Oncf R "vAS Tw" @ Hc@T TZoF |

ST@ gkALL@ R ArAAF@ jce "BU BU" UZ@ rFTU@pG WK ASAT AUZS ^r | WvArU cS R ZAS vgkAT@ UZ J "U@ ~Fg" w\Av (p 316) ~^gk a | j aR Ar gwF w\ AUZaS mSc, ArcT Oncf, Mf^TS TZoF, wMf oTU, HFU Oncf R ~SFSF J mgcAXo Q | Ar@ w\  ~AT j@cq gUcA S, c BAS AZ Av gwF Ar@ @ASf @- UZ@ R ~q A j r@ HABl  "ZAvTf c cW" (p 105) jce cXoc  AO "sT a@ cW"|

j a a ~eZF @Ac R a;  UZ@AU@AvR OT@ - ~AB , T^ ATn, ~^re@ , gK TZoF, Sf^S Oncf, BfTAS @ d @ ASTU^ wMT, TU @, U , AcS c R ~ ~ ~S@ | ~c@ Uw  P TBc ~AU UZ AUTA@ | c ATAU jq e@USAv ceU ArAF j@ BU esBS |

|| 3 ||

^r j@ ~AgSc O, s T@UfS ~SF Arr/A@r An@ OZ AS  U -" @c ~", w@ wA@ UZ aAc, @Ac, a, wF e@US  A eZF; Z UZ@ OT@ UZ,  ~S@ c  A@ ~v | jq@T j@Av O UqS UZ  ~T qha AaU @Ac UZ - mpA @ AUZAa, q gUR  , @AcAv AaU - "j@ s AaU PAS@/ rnT PAS@/j@AS  cUU J@/cq ~T q AS@ |" Zc c ZS OUa g A@mS sXo, q PAS@ ~SK ZS mpA cU | ~ j@Av eZF @Ar U ~T O c TSF c j@ A@r @Ac UZ cf^S j@ AcZF @Ac FA -

j @cU AS-n
O@ WK c wn
cp O ~e@ ArZc

TASf r  ca gfKH Z, mU Sf BU ~@U, TS ~a  U mU @ cA ~r r wm cA @ BU O A TvS @ | j@q T ~T mU jUS SS Tmv - T rS TS AaU rgA, wf TSK | ^r H Z ~T @@BS c^ ATU j@AS AaS cA c UZ U ~T FA - cf^S S, TokS -

"Jr@ wJ ~AaU sTA
 A, ~gwU AT HFcS
~A @AUABv mU ArU TA
pG ~@U an @A S" ... qFA |

BAS S F @SAS ZJB AaUS A@S jq ypA, c J mrfU r @SAS @TA AS | cTS w^ q c@U ~w  cf^S FAAv e@AU a (p 348) jce ~S@ S mpA A jU    | q gc  ST A@r jZS A@ AUZaS BS qha @ |

^r ~T T UZ @r ~ @@ ca  - Zc c 1973 c 74 ;  ~wR @c @Ac R a AiAa A@ TSSf AS | c AcU gwF Ar@ AaJU j@Av AcS AcK@ a ; ~qSmvqS R ~AQ@ LL en^ j@Av c OAU AUTA@ @  ~SH | @ Uv AAaUS ASAv eA jce STAvR - "~B@ Aw ~c A" STAv  JU B U "~T @v"| q T ~ScrF@ w @AaUT jq ~SAo@ cr, A@ jZS cI A s UZAv@ ^r @AO@JO i@ Ai@ Q ~@KHf @ U BSF AcSAU AaU j@^ BSf | TSSS ec R UfU TBT @Av ~S@AS sL @ ZAaUT, A@ cc Ai@S cUS @U @ A wa |  Ai@ B ~w TAS ~ UT JO v@ ^r An@  @ | ~@ml ~wT ~T AS ~S^ rK Sq | gAc @ ZS cTn @Ar a rA OoF r @Ac - TA\U@ m@U B j@c @ Aw  \v ~A; @S TAU@ AcS r xv cAr a A AB SS, A ZS OUa | v@v  U Zc Aco , A@ T cUU ^r  ^r A@S cq@ ZR, ~jc q q |

jq,  ^r mw^ cI Aw ASB  mpA IJA ZU cAa; s TA@ n ACS A^oF @vAaU ASB P@r,  caq @ OSAU A, AB e@US TS@ AA AS s U ~ ~f | 2003 j fc rf cU I, ATU R, ~Acr^ cpAS, AcrB T^ R Ac sXoASS J@ J@ cr @@Av ^ AS  @vU jq To w^i, BSF  ^r R  @r@@ BSq ~eZF, ~@i oSFc !

jq UZ ~S @TS UwU ?